Home

Is "great replacement" theory a dogma, conspiracy, or actually a good theory that fits the observations?

roc_abilly

Member
Anonymous said:
I would say you would shit your pants if an African looked sideways at you...
That's some projection, loser.

Another loser with his pants in a twist that someone is poking holes in his stupid fucking dogma.

Jambo said:
Find an article on replacement theory that doesn't say it's a conspiracy theory
Listen thicko, this is the last time.

This mUh CoNsPIraCy tHeORy shtick of yours is only your latest talking point. It hasn't been around long enough in far right meme land to be commented upon. Your telegram muses only recently came up with it.

Previous to that, any "far right" discussion of replacement theory always involved Jews, or elites orchestrating it, some cabal or other, in the tradition of the protocols, depending on the audience. It is that aspect of the theory that earns it the label "conspiracy theory".

Jambo said:
You have said that (the current wave of) immigration in Ireland is a S-shaped curve, what do you mean by that (and show us your work)?
See, you can't understand even one simple thing said to you.

What I pointed out was that there is a tenuous assumption in your sacrosanct replacement dogma that assumes projections based on linear growth. That assumption is total bollox.

Trees don't grow to the sky. There are always natural limits to growth. Growth in nature follows a sigmoid curve.

When your twitter gurus tell you "it's happening" they are theorising more or less linear growth straight through to the apocalyptic "replacement" scenario that plays to your fears.

Whereas even take total fertility rate for the world as a whole. Do you know it has plummeted since the 60s, well more than halved, ever closer to 2.1 (when Malthusian theory was in vogue and everyone thought the world would collapse under the weight of world population).

Now where might we be on such a sigmoid curve here in Ireland for example? I think we might well conjecture (considering for example just three weeks ago the serious tightening of immigration law) that we're at the point of levelling off. Just an opinion, granted, but still on a more solid base than your theories.

Basically your theory holds a myopic cut-off perspective of just one small part of the whole curve, assumes it must be the whole world forever, and therefore projects it linearly.

the-sigmoid-curve-depicting-the-growth-of-the-population-N-as-a-function-of-time-t_Q640.jpg


This is just one hole out of many in your theory. Perhaps @fucking fuck would like to add his two cents to hammer home just how big that hole is?

Ds86ds said:
left wing posters...
He-ar. If you're referring to me, I'm no more left wing than your granny.

I am just as scathing of cult-like and/or dogmatic thinking, and stupidity, and craven projections, and unquestioned assumptions, and egocentric feeling sorry for oneself, and competitive victimhood, and all the rest of it, over on the radical left as the far right.

I don't really care about James' politics, I am more concerned with his stupidity, lack of capability for critical thought, and falling into a cult.

I assure you I enjoy rubbing the noses of the left in their own scat as much as we're rubbing James' in it here.
 
That's some projection, loser.

Another loser with his pants in a twist that someone is poking holes in his stupid fucking dogma.
First of all, reply to different posts and to different people in different posts (of yours). Stop doing your Mowl impression.. I don't need to be scraping your shite away that you've posted to others when replying to what you've posted to me.

Listen thicko, this is the last time.

This mUh CoNsPIraCy tHeORy shtick of yours is only your latest talking point. It hasn't been around long enough in far right meme land to be commented upon. Your telegram muses only recently came up with it.
It has nothing to do with memes or Telegram muses dipshit, stop doing your Mowl impression

Previous to that, any "far right" discussion of replacement theory always involved Jews, or elites orchestrating it, some cabal or other, in the tradition of the protocols, depending on the audience. It is that aspect of the theory that earns it the label "conspiracy theory".
It's why it's called a "theory", the point I've been making all along..

See, you can't understand even one simple thing said to you.
Such as?

What I pointed out was that there is a tenuous assumption in your sacrosanct replacement dogma that assumes projections based on linear growth. That assumption is total bollox.
What's "replacement dogma"? I gave you my definition of replacement in post 26.

Trees don't grow to the sky. There are always natural limits to growth. Growth in nature follows a sigmoid curve.
So what it if it does?

When your twitter gurus tell you "it's happening" they are theorising more or less linear growth straight through to the apocalyptic "replacement" scenario that plays to your fears.
No, a current trajectory is being applied, that hasn't changed in decades.

Whereas even take total fertility rate for the world as a whole. Do you know it has plummeted since the 60s, well more than halved, ever closer to 2.1 (when Malthusian theory was in vogue and everyone thought the world would collapse under the weight of world population).
That must be why the world population has been increasing, Jesus 🙄

Of course, the reason for world population increase is not because white people/Europeans are the ones having all the babies

Now where might we be on such a sigmoid curve here in Ireland for example? I think we might well conjecture (considering for example just three weeks ago the serious tightening of immigration law) that we're at the point of levelling off. Just an opinion, granted, but still on a more solid base than your theories.
Conjecture? Are you predicting the future?

As for the serious tightening of immigration law, don't know what that is. Are you talking about the fact that the Irish government publicly stated that they currently cannot accommodate any more irregular migrants (at taxpayers' expense)?

Basically your theory
I don't have a theory

holds a myopic cut-off perspective of just one small part of the whole curve, assumes it must be the whole world forever, and therefore projects it linearly.

the-sigmoid-curve-depicting-the-growth-of-the-population-N-as-a-function-of-time-t_Q640.jpg


This is just one hole out of many in your theory. Perhaps @fucking fuck would like to add his two cents to hammer home just how big that hole is?
I don't have a theory, you have a (meaningless) S-shaped curve

He-ar. If you're referring to me, I'm no more left wing than your granny.

I am just as scathing of cult-like and/or dogmatic thinking, and stupidity, and craven projections, and unquestioned assumptions, and egocentric feeling sorry for oneself, and competitive victimhood, and all the rest of it, over on the radical left as the far right.

I don't really care about James' politics, I am more concerned with his stupidity, lack of capability for critical thought, and falling into a cult.

I assure you I enjoy rubbing the noses of the left in their own scat as much as we're rubbing James' in it here.
 
F

Fucking fuck.

Guest
This is just one hole out of many in your theory. Perhaps @fucking fuck would like to add his two cents to hammer home just how big that hole is?
His fucking theory has more holes than the face and arse of a fucking monkeypox victim. Fucking fuckwad still trying to pretend he is even fuckin stupider than he fucking is. What do you fucking say? Fucking candidate for replacement if ever I fucking saw one. Actually would you ever shut this fuckwitted fuck up rocker, one post making a synopsis of his stupid fucking memes is plenty. Go on ruthlessly edit that fucker so we don't have to endure his chinese fucking torture of his one repeated dog fucking stupid fucking lifted point driving repeatedly into all our fucking heads. And can't you see how it all fucking works this far right total fucking shite. Fucks sake. No fucking sense or sign of independent intelligence at all in these fuckers. No wonder those manipulative twitter fuckers are so easily able to play to their fears of being replaced, fucking waste of space, the lot of them.
 

Mowl

Member

Can't stop laughing at this one.

Is Mowl having a go on the sock today? 🤔

Mowl doesn't do socks, Jambo - I'm more than enough as it is.

Stop being so pathetically paranoid and insecure.

literally nobody in Ireland shares that "Roc" persons twisted views , I very much doubt that poster has any connection to Ireland whatsoever

I very much doubt your very much doubt.

And as it happens, his views are far more lucid than Jambo's fretful nationalistismical views.

That roc bastard is a Hasbara troll!

Yer Ma.
 
literally nobody in Ireland shares that "Roc" persons twisted views , I very much doubt that poster has any connection to Ireland whatsoever
Most of his eh, views seem to be a (poorly) rehashed hodgepodge of what he reads from American sources anyway. That and copying Mowl.
 
His fucking theory has more holes than the face and arse of a fucking monkeypox victim. Fucking fuckwad still trying to pretend he is even fuckin stupider than he fucking is. What do you fucking say? Fucking candidate for replacement if ever I fucking saw one. Actually would you ever shut this fuckwitted fuck up rocker, one post making a synopsis of his stupid fucking memes is plenty. Go on ruthlessly edit that fucker so we don't have to endure his chinese fucking torture of his one repeated dog fucking stupid fucking lifted point driving repeatedly into all our fucking heads. And can't you see how it all fucking works this far right total fucking shite. Fucks sake. No fucking sense or sign of independent intelligence at all in these fuckers. No wonder those manipulative twitter fuckers are so easily able to play to their fears of being replaced, fucking waste of space, the lot of them.
 

Mowl

Member
See? Waste of time getting involved in Jambo's deluded notions: if you let him, he'll drag you down into the deep dark of his infinite rabbit-holes. His is like a warren that never ends. Take one step in and you'll never get back out alive. He'd bore you to death with his incoherent rambling.
 
See? Waste of time getting involved in Jambo's deluded notions: if you let him, he'll drag you down into the deep dark of his infinite rabbit-holes. His is like a warren that never ends. Take one step in and you'll never get back out alive. He'd bore you to death with his incoherent rambling.
Fuckety Fuck reminds me of Mike Graham. You should watch that vid (it's hilarious)
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top Bottom